BHP’s permission to appeal is refused by the Supreme Court

June 6, 2023
Supreme Court Judgment

Global mining giant BHP suffered a humiliating defeat in its attempt to stop Pogust Goodhead’s lawsuit over Brazil’s worst ever environmental disaster, the Mariana dam disaster.

On 1 June 2023, the Supreme Court refused BHP’s permission to appeal, meaning the mining giant will have to face trial in October 2024. BHP was attempting to appeal the historic judgment that was handed down in July 2022, officially allowing the case, the largest group action in history, to be heard in the courts of England and Wales.

The June 2023 Supreme Court judgment states:

“The Court ordered that permission to appeal be REFUSED because the application does not raise an arguable point of law.”

Pogust Goodhead’s Global Managing Partner and CEO, Tom Goodhead, said:

“We are delighted that the Supreme Court has unanimously rejected BHP’s claim that this trial should not go ahead. It is yet another desperate and embarrassing attempt by BHP to try and shirk responsibility and deny the pain and devastation it has caused because it values profit over people’s lives.

“Rather than write yet another chapter in the handbook for corporate wrongdoing, it is time BHP do the right thing by the real victims here, our clients, who have been left to suffer with the catastrophic devastation to their families, homes, land, and way of life.”

More Press

Mariana dam disaster damage in Brazil
Important update on the Mariana Case in England (Hearing held on 2 and 3 July 2025)
This week, an important hearing took place which marked the beginning of the second phase of the case. Here are the key points: The Court will now begin...
Read More
Justice
London court to hold hearing on damages phase of Mariana case on 2 and 3 July 
Mayor of Mariana, Juliano Duarte, and Marcelo Krenak, one of the leaders of the Krenak indigenous community, will be in London for a hearing to organise...
Read More
Disaster in Maceió - Braskem Case
After Braskem SA found liable for disaster in Maceió, Brazilian victims appeal to Dutch court against European subsidiaries 
After Braskem SA found liable for disaster in Maceió, Brazilian victims appeal to Dutch court against European subsidiaries Appeal was filed on Tuesday...
Read More