Mariana dam disaster claim update: High Court reject Vale’s bid to block BHP lawsuit 

August 7, 2023
Mariana fishing before the dam collapse

In the most recent case advancement, Vale has lost its bid to block BHP’s request to share any potential liability in the Mariana dam disaster claim. The claim is currently the largest group litigation in English legal history.

Vale and BHP as co-defendants  

London’s High Court was asked to rule if Vale should be added as a co-defendant in our claim against BHP on behalf of the victims of Brazil’s worst ever environmental disaster.  

BHP, which denies liability, claimed that Vale should join the case to share in any potential liability and contribute to damages if they are found liable for the damage caused to people’s livelihoods, the environment, and nearby local communities.

Vale’s responsibility in London  

Despite Vale’s argument that the dispute between it and BHP should be heard in Brazil, Judge Finola O’Farrell rejected the challenge. She said the claim ‘essentially mirrored the claimants’ case against BHP’ and should therefore be decided as part of the existing lawsuit. 

Tom Goodhead, Global Managing Partner and CEO, said: “BHP has previously told the court in London that the inclusion of Vale in the process would mean a settlement would be more likely, and we hold them to their word.  

“It’s time for BHP and Vale to both do the right thing and engage with the claimants in this case to reach an effective resolution.”  

The Mariana dam disaster claim  

Pogust Goodhead is representing more than 700,000 people in the Mariana dam disaster claim who have all suffered loss as a result of the dam collapse in 2015.  

You can find out more about the claim or take a look at the latest news and updates via the Pogust Goodhead website. 

More Press

Francisco Proner - Brumadinho - Francisco Proner - Brumadinho - DJI_0650
Caso Brumadinho avança: tribunal de Munique agenda audiências para maio em ação contra certificadora TÜV SÜD
Desde 2019, mais de 1.400 requerentes movem a ação judicial; indenização total exigida da TÜV SÜD totaliza R$ 3,2 bilhões Sete anos após o rompimento...
Read More
Francisco Proner - Brumadinho - Francisco Proner - Brumadinho - DJI_0650
Brumadinho case moves forward: Munich court schedules hearings for May in lawsuit against TÜV SÜD 
Since 2019, more than 1,400 claimants have brought legal proceedings; total compensation sought from TÜV SÜD amounting to R$3.2 billion Seven years after...
Read More
Francisco Proner - Londres Julgamento-1012671
Desastre de Mariana: Tribunal Superior da Inglaterra nega pedido da BHP para recorrer de decisão histórica que condenou mineradora 
 A juíza O’Farrell manteve entendimento que reconheceu a responsabilidade da empresa anglo-australiana pelo pior desastre ambiental do Brasil  Londres,...
Read More